How to pick a Maryland blue crab

Eating Steamed Crabs in Maryland

Are you picking your Maryland blue crabs the right way?
You’ve just returned from a crabbing charter in Ocean City, Maryland, and you’ve got a fresh batch of steamed blue crabs in front of you. Now what? For many Marylanders, it’s downright painful to watch a first-timer leave behind all that delicious meat. Don’t worry — we’re here to help you pick like a pro. Grab some melted butter, Old Bay, a few sheets of newspaper, and a little patience. It’s time to dive in.

🦀 30 Crab Picking Tips from Captain Nick (Straight Outta Ocean City)

  1. Start with a hot crab: Cold crabs are like cold showers — uncomfortable and not very productive. Give ’em a steam and let’s get to work.
  2. Pop the apron: That triangle on the belly? Lift it and launch your crab-picking journey like you just found the treasure map under the lid.
  3. Snap it in half: Break that bad boy in two like you’re cracking a glow stick. It’ll make things way easier.
  4. Mustard is optional: That yellow goo? Marylanders call it “mustard.” Some eat it. Some nope right out. Ocean City law says you gotta at least try it once.
  5. Put down the mallet: This isn’t whack-a-mole. Use your hands or a butter knife. Keep it surgical, not savage.
  6. Thumbs up: Your best tools are built in. Use your thumbs like Mother Nature intended — for maximum crab meat extraction.
  7. Avoid the gills: They’re called “dead man’s fingers” for a reason. Toss ‘em, don’t taste ‘em.
  8. Start with the backfin: That’s the good stuff. Like the filet mignon of crab meat. Don’t blow it.
  9. Claw twist, don’t smash: Snap it gently and pull. If it explodes like confetti, you’re doing it wrong (and wearing it).
  10. Use the tip trick: Crack the skinny claw tip first. It’s like uncorking a bottle of pure Maryland flavor.
  11. Turn claw into tool: Stuck leg meat? Use a claw tip like a local and poke it out. Crafty and crabby — just like Ocean City.
  12. Control the chaos: Elbows in. Don’t crab like you’re directing traffic on Coastal Highway.
  13. Napkins are a myth: Real OC pickers use newspaper and a will to survive. Old Bay builds character.
  14. Shells aren’t snacks: You’d be surprised how many people need to hear this. Don’t chew it. Chuck it.
  15. Watch a local: Park yourself next to an old-timer. You’ll learn more than from any crab blog (yes, even this one).
  16. Quiet = full plate: The guy not talking is the guy eating. Take notes. Then take meat.
  17. Old Bay fingers are a lifestyle: Accept it. Just don’t touch your eyes. Or your phone. Or your dog.
  18. Check the knuckles: Those joints where the legs attach? That’s bonus meat. Like finding fries at the bottom of the bag.
  19. Trash here, treasure there: Build two piles — meat and mess. If your plate looks like a hurricane hit a seafood shack, reset.
  20. Dip like you mean it: Butter, vinegar, hot sauce — your call. Just don’t drown the flavor. This is Ocean City, not a soup kitchen.
  21. Use a shell bucket: Crabs smell great until 20 empty shells say otherwise. Keep it clean, captain.
  22. Cold drink = hot crab energy: Beer, soda, sweet tea — keep something cold in your other hand and life’s better. Trust me.
  23. Teach the kids: Show the little ones the way. Childhood memories taste like crab and Old Bay.
  24. Take your time: This isn’t a race — it’s a ritual. Enjoy it like an OC sunset on the bay.
  25. Have extra knives: Someone’s gonna drop one. Possibly in their drink. Be ready.
  26. Dress for mess: Leave the nice stuff at home. Wear something that screams “I eat with my hands.”
  27. Claws deserve respect: Don’t rush the claw. That’s top-shelf meat. Take your time and admire your work.
  28. Stack shells with pride: Neat piles of picked shells are like trophies. It says “I came, I clawed, I conquered.”
  29. Try a crab shot: Mustard, vinegar, maybe a little beer. It’s weird. It’s local. You’ll probably love it.
  30. Embrace the chaos: It’s crab season in Ocean City. You’re gonna get messy, smell like seafood, and tell the story all year. That’s the point.

How to Pick Crabs Like a Local

Check out our videos and links to expert crab pickers below. Study up, and then join us for a hands-on crabbing experience aboard one of our Get Sum Charters!

Learn to Pick Like a Pro!


Watch on YouTube →

Don’t leave good crab meat behind! This clear, step-by-step video walks you through how to pick a Maryland blue crab efficiently — from removing the apron to cracking the claws and scooping the sweet backfin. If you’re new to eating steamed crabs or just want to sharpen your skills, this video will help you make the most of every bite.

How to Pick Maryland Blue Crabs Like a Maryland Native!


Watch on YouTube →

This video shows how true Marylanders pick blue crabs — quickly, cleanly, and with no meat wasted. You’ll learn the traditional Chesapeake Bay techniques passed down through generations. Perfect for visitors who want to blend in at the crab feast and locals looking to refine their approach.

Picking Crabs with the Famous


Watch on YouTube →

Straight from the tables of Jimmy’s Famous Seafood, this video brings insider knowledge from one of Maryland’s most iconic crab houses. Learn how the pros do it—efficient, clean, and with zero shell drama. It’s like a behind-the-scenes masterclass for anyone serious about picking blue crabs the right way.

How to Pick a Blue Crab


Watch on YouTube →

This beginner-friendly guide covers all the basics of how to pick a Maryland blue crab, from breaking it open to removing the meat cleanly. With clear camera angles and straightforward steps, it’s perfect for first-timers who want to learn the process without getting overwhelmed.

Learn to Pick Like a Pro!


Watch on YouTube →

Don’t leave good crab meat behind! This clear, step-by-step video walks you through how to pick a Maryland blue crab efficiently — from removing the apron to cracking the claws and scooping the sweet backfin. If you’re new to eating steamed crabs or just want to sharpen your skills, this video will help you make the most of every bite.

How To Pick a Crab, MARYLAND STYLE!


Watch on YouTube →

This quick YouTube Short packs a punch with a fast demonstration of true Maryland-style crab picking. Watch the essentials of cracking, peeling, and scooping boiled down into under a minute — perfect for a refresher or a quick intro before your next crab feast.

How to Pick Maryland Blue Crabs


Watch on YouTube →

This full-length tutorial offers a complete look at how to properly pick Maryland blue crabs, from claws to body meat. With detailed visuals and step-by-step explanations, it’s a great video for anyone looking to get serious about crab picking — whether you’re prepping for your first crab feast or just want to stop wasting meat.

Crab Picking with the Pros


Watch on YouTube →

Ever wonder how the professionals pick crabs so fast and clean? This video gives you a front-row seat to the techniques used by seasoned crab pickers. From efficient claw cracking to scooping out every pocket of meat, you’ll pick up valuable tips to bring to your next crab feast.

How to PROPERLY Pick & Eat Maryland Blue Crabs


Watch on YouTube →

If you’ve ever second-guessed your crab-picking skills, this video is your go-to guide. It walks you through the proper way to pick and eat a Maryland blue crab — from cleaning to extracting every tender bite. Learn the do’s and don’ts, avoid common mistakes, and enjoy every shell-cracking minute.

Pick Maryland Blue Crabs Like a Pro


Watch on YouTube →

This helpful tutorial breaks down efficient crab picking into a repeatable rhythm. From expertly snapping claws to effortlessly pulling out body meat, you’ll see how the pros get the most out of every crab. Great for improving your technique and picking speed without sacrificing any flavor.